Speaking Of Colostrum and Meniere's

Discussion in 'Your Living Room' started by Vicki, Dec 23, 2014.

  1. June-

    June- Well-Known Member

    1,789
    58
    48
    May 12, 2014
    I keep comparing the two to illustrate that medicines are often nonspecific. Think advil then.
     
  2. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    true the colostrum is non specific but with specific antibodies in it (like the patented product I posted) it becomes disease specific.
     
  3. June-

    June- Well-Known Member

    1,789
    58
    48
    May 12, 2014
    But not for menieres. There is no menieres antibody. So the improvement in menieres patients would have to be from a more general route, wouldn't it?
     
  4. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    it depends on what causes Meniere's or hydrops, Meniere's is a result of something, an infection of some sort.
     
  5. June-

    June- Well-Known Member

    1,789
    58
    48
    May 12, 2014
    Not necessarily. It can be an autoimmune response.
     
  6. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    but wouldn't there need to be something that caused the response, as in all autoimmune diseases, the body cant distinguish between antigens and healthy tissues, many believe its a virus, bacteria or drugs that cause this confusion.
     
  7. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    that's exactly what happens when we get an allergic reaction to food, the body thinks the non threatening protein is going to harm us, so the immune system bombards us with histamines to protect us, that over production of histamines is what is the allergic response, hives etc
     
  8. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    oops I meant to say that over production of histamines is what is the allergic reaction is, hives etc
     
  9. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    but something is causing our immune system to be confused and not being able to distinguish good from bad.
     
  10. June-

    June- Well-Known Member

    1,789
    58
    48
    May 12, 2014
    Yes. That i the problem when people are susceptible to auto immune diseases.
     
  11. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    From everything I have read about food allergies and their theories why its becoming an epidemic, I'm fairly certain my food allergy happened due to a drug, a proton pump inhibitor, Prilosec.
     
  12. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    I am going to a well known Dr/researcher associated with Mt Sinai Hospital which is the allergy research center of the world, next month, she developed a Chinese herbal medication that prevents anaphylaxis in case of cross contact or ingestion of ones allergen. I am going to ask her about Meniere's pertaining to her field of Chinese Herbal Medicine since she appears familiar with the connection between allergies and MM.
     
  13. June-

    June- Well-Known Member

    1,789
    58
    48
    May 12, 2014
    Let us know what she says.
     
  14. Halos

    Halos Member

    143
    3
    16
    May 21, 2014
    If we knew the fungus, virus, or allergen that caused our menieres could we not take a deactivated version of that pathogen and combine it with something like colostrum to help us just like they do with the flu vaccine.
     
  15. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    I agree Trisha that's what I was thinking and mentioned earlier.
     
  16. June-

    June- Well-Known Member

    1,789
    58
    48
    May 12, 2014
    But you dont have to wait for that. You can take an antiviral or antifungal without knowing that. Just offer that so you dont have to wait for 20 years. Also it may turn out that it is not a specific virus or fungus, it may be any of many such problems can produce an immune response that causes menieres. It would be more convenient if it was just one thing and always that one thing but many times, that is not the case and this may be one of those times.
     
  17. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    true antivirals etc are extremely helpful but its really just a bandaid not a cure but thank goodness! for them or I would still have vertigo
     
  18. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    here is a new study which isolates antigens in inner ear autoimmune disease
    Autoimmune Disease of the Inner Ear Workup
    Updated: Oct 14, 2014

    Antigen-nonspecific tests are useful in routine screening for evidence of systemic immunologic dysfunction, yet specifically are not known to correlate with a diagnosis of immune-mediated inner ear disease. Antigen-nonspecific tests are as follows:

    •Levels of circulating immune complexes


    •Complement levels (C3, C4)


    •Antinuclear antibody levels


    •Rheumatoid factor


    •Acute phase reactants - Erythrocyte sedimentation rate, C-reactive protein


    A study by Dayal et al discovered that patients with autoimmune ear disease having no systemic autoimmune illness often show high levels of antinuclear antibodies (with a speckled pattern) and also sometimes have high levels of rheumatoid factor. The positive yield of other detailed tests was low.[6]

    A study by Svrakic et al indicated that tumor necrosis factor (TNF) levels can be used diagnostically and prognostically in immune-mediated inner ear disease. The study, which involved 85 patients with clinical and audiometric characteristics of immune-mediated SNHL, as well as 11 controls, found that patients with immune-mediated SNHL who were nonresponsive to steroids had a higher mean baseline plasma level of TNF (27.6 pg/mL), as derived from peripheral venous blood, than did those who were responsive to steroids (24.1 pg/mL), and that both had higher TNF levels than did the controls (14.4 pg/mL). According to the investigators, a baseline plasma TNF level of more than 18.8 pg/mL from the peripheral circulation has a positive predictive value for immune-mediated SNHL of more than 97%.[7]

    Svrakic and colleagues also found evidence that in non-steroid-responsive patients with immune-mediated SNHL, peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) respond differently to in vitro stimulation with dexamethasone than do those of steroid-responsive patients, with the mean TNF level secreted by the PBMCs slightly increasing (from 11.2 pg/mL to 11.7 pg/mL) with stimulation instead of decreasing.[7]

    Antigen-specific tests are as follows:

    •Migration inhibition assay: The patient's lymphocytes are placed in a capillary tube with serum containing inner ear antigens present on one end. If the patient's lymphocytes previously have been sensitized to the inner ear antigen, migration inhibition factor is released and impedes dispersion of lymphocytes from the tube. This assay is a gross test of immune reactivity.


    •Lymphocyte transformation test (LTT): The LTT measures the response of the patient's sensitized lymphocytes to known inner ear antigens. The patient's lymphocytes are exposed to serum containing inner ear antigens. A proliferative response occurs and is compared to that of known negative control lymphocytes. Measurement is made by recording the incorporation of tritiated thymidine into new DNA as cell synthesis occurs. Sensitivity of the LTT is reported to be 50-80% when symptoms are active in an immunocompetent patient.


    •Western blot analysis for antibodies to inner ear antigen ◦Harris and Sharp used bovine inner ear extract as antigen in Western blot assays and detected antibody to a 68-kd inner ear antigen in 19 of 54 patients (35%) with progressive SNHL. Recent update includes a cohort of 279 patients with rapidly progressive SNHL, of whom 90 (32%) had positive results of Western blot analysis for the 68-kd antibody.
    ◦Animals with experimentally induced SNHL possessed autoantibodies to the identical component of the inner ear antigenic isotope to which patients' sera reacted.
    ◦Moscicki et al confirmed the finding of circulating antibodies against a 68-kd protein, which was found in 42 of 72 patients (58%) with IPBSNHL.[8] Patients with positive test results for the antibody were more likely than those with negative results to have hearing loss that responded to steroid treatment (75% vs 18%). This study is the first to show a correlation between Western blot 68-kd positivity and steroid responsiveness.
    ◦Rauch subsequently identified the 68-kd protein as heat shock protein 70 (HSP 70).[9] Heat shock proteins are constitutively produced by host and pathogens and usually are up-regulated in response to infection or other stresses.
    ◦Antibodies to HSP 70 were detected in 47% of 30 patients with Ménière disease, thus identifying a subset of patients with Ménière disease with an immune basis for their symptoms.
    ◦The LTT and Western blot immunoassay must be performed in specialized immunology laboratories, often on a send-out basis.
    ◦Control populations vary from persons with normal hearing to those with systemic autoimmune diseases. The 68-kd positivity in these control populations averages 5%. This specificity of approximately 95% appears fairly high but is rather insensitive when used in the general population.
    ◦Gong et al found that 2 subcomponents of crude inner ear antigen (the 31 kD protein and the 60 kD protein) may induce autoimmune inner ear disease independently in the guinea pig cochlea.[10] The 31 kD protein may correspond to the 30 kD protein identified by Cao et al as myelin protein zero (P0), which is derived from the acoustic nerve and spiral ganglion.[11] The 31 kD protein may be of use in the future for early diagnosis of autoimmune inner ear disease (AIED).
     
  19. Vicki

    Vicki Guest

    the thing is other studies find a percentage of different antigens in the inner ear, doesn't seem to be 100% of any one antigen so far, so it seems it depends on the individual, which I think makes it extremely hard to cure MM.
     
  20. yellow

    yellow Member

    156
    2
    18
    May 13, 2014
    Keep going Vicki. I think that you might be straying into the territory of the Aussie Wizard (he who shall not be named) but I have always thought that he was/is onto something.

    PRPs, cytokines, immune dysfunctions are all familiar sounding landmarks.

    The thing I don’t get is that MM seems to be so idiosyncratic and so a one size fits all solution seems oxymoronic. Nor have I ever understood how a systemic problem only manifests itself in one ear.
     

Share This Page